Aspiring community of priests in St. Paul grounded in prayer, study and apostolic work

Share:
Facebook
X
Pinterest
WhatsApp
From left, Fathers Kyle Etzel, Bryce Evans and Byron Hagan. The three Catholic priests and one novice, layman Kai Olson, are growing in fraternal, communal life to become an established local household of the worldwide Oratory of St. Philip Neri. The household, whose members live adjacent to St. Mary in St. Paul’s Lowertown neighborhood, is currently a “community-in-formation.” DAVE HRBACEK | THE CATHOLIC SPIRIT

In St. Paul’s Lowertown neighborhood, three Catholic priests — Fathers Kyle Etzel, Bryce Evans and Byron Hagan — and one novice, layman Kai Olson, are growing in fraternal, communal life to become an established local household of the worldwide Oratory of St. Philip Neri.

The Rome-based Office of the Procurator General of the Confederation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri sent a letter dated June 29, 2025 — the feast of Sts. Peter and Paul — informing the household, whose members live adjacent to St. Mary in St. Paul, of its “community-in-formation” status.

“Starting an oratory here in the Twin Cities goes back quite a long ways to men in seminary” contemplating communal life, said Father Evans, a member of the aspiring oratory and co-pastor of St. Mary. “We were all seminarians when it began,” said Father Hagan, also a member of the aspiring oratory and co-pastor of St. Mary.

“In 2017, there was a first stab of beginning the oratory in Northeast Minneapolis with some of the priests and Father Hagan and I were eventually both part of that project,” Father Evans said. “And it’s had various waves and various renditions through the years.”

Fathers Evans and Hagan moved to St. Mary’s campus in the summer of 2021 and “then-Deacon Kyle Etzel spent a summer with us” the following year, Father Evans said, all of which built momentum for this “most recent rendition” of the aspiring oratory.

“(W)e’re happy to have kind of gained steam here in the last five years,” Father Evans said.

The origins of this communal way of living date to the 16th century when St. Philip Neri founded the first oratory in Rome. Around his ordination as a Catholic priest, St. Philip Neri gathered a community of young men — eventually including other ordained priests — for prayer meetings, spiritually-focused conversation and works of charity.

“The original founding of the oratory was also very organic,” Father Evans said. St. Philip Neri, he said, “didn’t set out to found something; he just attracted people to pray with him, to have spiritual conversation with him, to engage in apostolic works with him. And this — that regular habit — established a network of spiritual friendships.”

This first community became known for its contributions to the revitalization of the Rome diocese and it became the first “oratorian” household. Pope Gregory XIII canonically established the Confederation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri in 1575.

The spread of these Catholic communities — called oratories — is thanks in part to St. John Henry Newman. The doctor of the Church founded an oratory in England in 1848 and thus introduced the oratory to the English-speaking world.

According to the Confederation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri’s website, there are 87 oratories consisting of more than 470 members in 19 countries. Classified as a Society of Apostolic Life of the Clergy of Pontifical Right, each oratory is independent — often with its own provost, who is “like a superior,” Father Etzel said — but the oratories collectively form the confederation. The confederation’s procurator general presents confederation concerns to the Vatican.

“It might be the shortest hierarchical flow chart in the Church,” said Father Etzel, a member of the aspiring oratory as well as parochial vicar at the Cathedral of St. Paul in St. Paul and a chaplain and instructor at Unity Catholic High School in Burnsville.

An oratory begins as “a pious household, which is really simply an arrangement with the local bishop to allow some men to live together and try to pursue something common,” Father Evans said. “And that can be an indefinite amount of time in which that stage lasts.”

Father Evans said that once the pious household demonstrates its members live complementarily and collectively in pursuit of the oratory’s goals, with the bishop’s approval — in this case, Archbishop Bernard Hebda’s approval — the household can make a formal petition to the Confederation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri, to be established as a community-in-formation.

As Father Evans described it, during the minimally three-year process of being a community-in-formation, “we have the responsibility to fortify our lives, to make sure that we’re living up to what the oratorian tradition calls us to.”

This tradition is rooted in the community values of prayer, study and apostolic work. No formal vows are made as part of being in an oratory. “The oratory is not a religious order — we don’t take vows,” Father Evans said. “St. Philip really wanted it to be very free for the men, and he wanted it to be very familial and bonded in mutual affection for one another.”

As for the households themselves, “ideally they don’t get too large,” Father Evans said.

“St. John Henry Newman articulates this ethic where each man needs to know the other man’s face,” he said. “So, houses can’t get so large that every man doesn’t have a personal relationship with each man. So therefore, oratories don’t usually get much larger than 12 to 15 men.”

Oratory “discernment is a really intentional and slow thing as well,” Father Etzel said.

A universal constitution ensures oratorian households maintain their responsibilities but remains broad in its requirements. Father Evans said this is to allow each household “to figure out how to particularize the customs for their own time and place. So, there’s a lot of flexibility in what each oratorian household looks like.”

Still, “in the best situations, you’ll find that there’s something of the imitation of the original founding in the founding of other oratory houses,” Father Hagan said. “And that means that we remain not simply a clerical society — which is about simply personal cultivation of a way of internal life in the house — but rather, it’s the case that our lives are shared with one another and integrated with one another.”

Oratorians strive to live in simplicity and dedicate themselves to lifelong friendship with their fellow oratorians. Included in this dedication is communal prayer and other communal activities, like shared meals and shared spiritual study. Father Evans views this sharing of daily life with his fellow oratorians as an opportunity to be oriented toward others.

“There is something to having very clearly placed before you that your spiritual life isn’t just about you — it’s something you’re engaging with others for the sake of others,” he said. “(D)aily commitments to common prayer and common life help place that right in front of you in very concrete and practical ways every day.”

Father Etzel agreed. “The way that we live puts immediately in front of you the need to live the Gospel,” he said.

“(W)hen we have our morning time of meditation and prayer together, when one is absent, that affects me, and it’s like a part of the body is not there,” Father Etzel said. He said he draws strength from “that daily reminder (that) our hearts are intended, without a vow, to be made into one in a very familial way.”

The ‘lay oratory’ and connecting with other oratorians

As co-pastors of St. Mary, Father Evans said that for himself and Father Hagan, “the mission of St. Mary’s and the mission of the (aspiring) oratory are deeply intertwined for us.”

“It’s always the endeavor of the oratory to have a permanent home in a precise physical location,” Father Evans said; for this community-in-formation, the location has inspired new involvement.

“One of our things we’ve been most encouraged by, in our efforts here at St. Mary’s, has been the closeness of friendships we’ve developed with our lay partners in trying to build something special here in terms of community and apostolate,” Father Evans said.

In addition to “being a fraternal community of priests for their own sanctification,” an oratory’s mission must also consist of building “a community of laypeople who want to pray with, and receive formation from, and engage in apostolic works with the priests,” Father Evans explained. “It’s sometimes called the ‘lay oratory’ or the ‘secular oratory’ or the ‘little oratory.’”

Oratories often extend their ministry to laypeople and collaborate on apostolic initiatives — “closeness to the laity, inviting the laity into the mission, that’s a very important dimension of the oratory,” Father Evans said.

Father Hagan expanded upon this by saying, “St. Philip’s oratory very much anticipates the spirit of the Second Vatican Council in its call for the active participation of the laity in apostolic life and in charismatic movements.”

He went on to say that “at its best, oratories retain something of a freshness and a charismatic creativity. And that’s what we’re really committed to — preserving and being open to that.”

“(M)ost of our lay oratorians, I would say, are parishioners here at St. Mary’s,” Father Etzel said. “We have people that participate just as frequently as any of those in lay oratory life and events that are from other parishes, too, all mostly from around here.”

Interested laypeople currently gather monthly to pray together with the members of the community-in-formation. “After the Holy Hour, we come here (to the household) oftentimes for some spiritual conversation or a lesson from one of the priests together with some time for a good conversation amongst friends and a little reception,” Father Evans said.

The priests reflected on a recent such gathering that “happened to fall nicely on St. Patrick’s Day, which allowed us to ease up on our Lenten disciplines just a little bit,” Father Evans said humorously.

Father Etzel said there were “kids running around, and pregnant couples, and elderly” attendees. “That’s one of the things I love about it … it’s pretty intergenerational.”

“I love having these elderly (attendees) with us, or the moms who are a little more into momhood helping the new moms, or (the) recently married, or (those) helping the ever-wandering single young adults navigate those things,” Father Etzel said. “That’s just kind of happened naturally from some of these various events.”

Another event that has garnered interest and consistent attendance among young adults has been Beads and Beers — a walk within the Lowertown neighborhood during which the rosary is prayed, then beverages at a local establishment.

“We might stop and talk to people on the way if we’re asked for money or such things,” Father Evans said.

“Usually we’re asked for prayer,” Father Etzel said.

“It’s kind of a gentle public witness,” Father Evans said.

It’s a public witness that has received broader attention, with Father Etzel remarking that the staff at Barrel Theory Beer Company has gotten to know the Beads and Beers group well.

“We’ve been invited to their weddings, we hear about their broken furnaces,” Father Etzel said. “They know when it’s Lent and Advent because we’re not there.”

The three priests explained that each diocese can have an oratory, but not all do; the aspiring oratorians communicate with other oratorians, to ask questions and seek advice.

“We maintain contact with them to kind of help us along the way,” Father Evans said, adding that the local group has visited some of the 13 oratories in North America, including in Philadelphia; Pittsburgh; Toronto; and Washington, D.C.

“We visited the oratory in Vienna, which is very successful and has a nearly 50-year existence,” Father Hagan recounted. These oratorians “have been very influential, too, with respect to the success of their sacred arts program and have been a great inspiration to us on that.”

From that inspiration has grown the aspiring oratory’s participation in the local arts. Through its “cultural calendar,” the aspiring oratorians have organized cultural events with corresponding conversations. Participants have visited Open Window Theatre in Inver Grove Heights; and the Guthrie Theater and Minneapolis Institute of Art, both in Minneapolis; as well as taking in the “symphony and opera,” Father Etzel said.

“(W)e try to encourage Catholic engagement with the arts that way,” Father Evans said.

In connection with Archbishop Hebda’s invitation to form small groups via the Parish Evangelization Cells System has been the community-in-formation’s creation of “oratory circles,” said Father Evans.

“We have a number of these to try and cultivate spiritual friendship amongst the people who are close to us, and we’ll try to chaplain these groups or shepherd these groups as we can,” he said.

The community-in-formation has also created a pamphlet that recommends various practices to unite its members “under the spiritual fatherhood of St. Philip.” In the pamphlet’s section on apostolic outreach, for example, lay oratorians are encouraged to pray about apostolic outreach “they can propose to the Fathers and execute under their supervision” and seek activities that “focus on the two-fold priority of charity to the poor and evangelical witness.”

The community-in-formation also intends to continue its practice of an annual retreat. “This last year we were able to have a common retreat together locally, just kind of over a weekend with our lay friends, just to try to deepen the vision of what we’re after,” Father Evans said.

Father Evans acknowledged an effort made by the aspiring oratory to try different things.

“We have many experiments underway right now, which have already been, I think, very fruitful,” he said. “I think we do have a real community of people forming with us, although maybe there’s a lot of different sides to it that have not yet fully coalesced.”

Becoming formally established

Ahead for the community-in-formation is the crafting of the house statutes, in consultation with other oratories.

“Each house has particular statutes to talk about how they’re going to govern their lives together,” Father Evans explained.

During its probationary period as a community-in-formation, aspiring oratorians continue to build their commitment to living in the ways outlined by St. Philip. The community-in-formation will receive at least one more visit from a representative of the Confederation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri “to kind of check in on us, and he’ll live with us and see how things are going, and tell us what we need to work on,” Father Evans said.

Father Etzel said that during this probationary period, he is looking forward to seeing what “spiritual goods” develop, “in terms of love for one another and working together and living together and the spiritual fruits of those things.”

Once the probationary period is determined to be complete, “then we can, with the archbishop’s approval and cooperation, formally petition to be established as a full-fledged oratory,” Father Evans said.

Father Evans explained that “once an oratory is fully established, the men, if they were diocesan priests, are no longer diocesan priests. … (T)hey’re incardinated into the household of the oratory” and are considered secular priests. Father Hagan said that this doesn’t remove the oratory from its local connections and that close collaboration with diocesan bishops, including Archbishop Hebda, would continue.

Father Hagan said the support the community-in-formation has received from the archbishop — “who has taken a special interest in sponsoring our development and foundation here” — has been especially rewarding.

“When one feels in ministry that your heart is really kind of tuning up with the bishop in a special way in a certain moment, it’s deeply consoling and encouraging,” Father Hagan said.

Fathers Evans and Etzel agreed.

“He’s been very, very supportive,” Father Evans said.

“I’m very grateful for Archbishop Hebda, that he’s our shepherd, and that our project coalesced with him being here is probably something more than coincidence,” Father Etzel said.


FEAST DAY CELEBRATION

Three Catholic priests and one novice have set up an opportunity to learn more about their “community-in-formation” to become an established local household of the worldwide Oratory of St. Philip Neri.

The three priests — Fathers Kyle Etzel, Bryce Evans and Byron Hagan — and one novice, layman Kai Olson, are hosting a gathering May 26, which is also the feast day of St. Philip Neri.

Father Evans described the event as a chance “to gather as many friends as we can and people who are curious about the oratory, who might want to support the oratory, to come join us for prayer and Mass and then dinner and we’ll give a talk.”

The event, held on the campus of St. Mary in St. Paul’s Lowertown neighborhood, will begin with a Holy Hour at 4 p.m., followed by Mass at 5 p.m., a reception and dinner at 6:30 p.m. and compline at 8:45 p.m.

Event and ticket information

Learn more about the community-in-formation in St. Paul

Share:
Facebook
X
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Related

McDonald sisters leave CSJ legacy

Why I am Catholic — Teresa Edalí Méndez Ortega

Bishop Izen: “(It’s) never too early to start teaching the faith”

Free Newsletter
Only Jesus
Trending

Before You Go!

Sign up for our free newsletter!

Keep up to date with what’s going on in the Catholic world