
This spring the Minnesota Legislature has been considering legislation to require insurance plans in the state to cover costly in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments which, while attempting to help women achieve pregnancy, inevitably destroy human embryos.
Legislators weren’t expected to pass the mandate before the session’s scheduled end May 18. But if the legislation supported by some members of both parties passes in the future, the cost is likely to be passed on to insurance plan members through their premiums, said Maggee Hangge, assistant director for operations and family policy at the Minnesota Catholic Conference (MCC), the public policy voice of the Catholic Church in Minnesota.
While scaling back some provisions of the proposal, lawmakers added an exemption to the mandate for religious organizations.
But they voted down an amendment to add restorative reproductive medicine to the insurance mandate. Restorative reproductive medicine is a comprehensive approach to fertility care designed to treat and cure underlying diseases, such as endometriosis, that can cause women’s infertility, Hangge said. That approach helps many couples conceive naturally, she said.
The mandate would also allow for commercial surrogacy if men wanted to conceive children through IVF, she said. The Catholic Church opposes IVF treatment and human surrogacy, MCC officials said.
Compassion for couples bearing the burden of infertility includes the call to help them with the best tools possible, Hangge said in her opposition to the mandate at an April 9 hearing of the Minnesota House Commerce Finance and Policy Committee. “That is not through pushing expensive and ethically questionable treatments like IVF but rather by finding and treating the root cause of infertility through restorative reproductive medicine,” Hangge said.
Couples deserve real answers about their fertility through restorative reproductive medicine rather than IVF, Hangge said, and “Minnesota taxpayers should not be forced to fund this unethical and often ineffective practice.”
IVF is the most common type of assisted reproductive technology. It involves surgically removing eggs from a woman’s ovaries, combining them with sperm in the laboratory and returning them to a female patient or gestational carrier, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
During the IVF process, a woman’s ovaries are stimulated by medication to release as many eggs as possible to create embryos for more implantation rounds; embryos that are not used are kept frozen, said Renee Oakes, director of the Department of Marriage, Family and Life in the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis’ Office of Discipleship and Evangelization. Oakes also founded and owns Integrated Fertility Care in Stillwater. In addition to Hangge, Oakes testified against the legislation at the April 9 hearing.

For each embryo implanted, it is estimated that five to six are discarded, Oakes told lawmakers. Overall, 90 percent are either destroyed, donated to science or kept in storage, creating a tremendous loss of life, she said. The number of frozen embryos in the U.S. is estimated to be in the millions, she said.
The Catholic Church teaches that the conception of a child must be safeguarded by ethical boundaries. The fact it can be achieved through technological means does not make it just for the parents, child or society, MCC officials said.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that, “Techniques that entail the dissociation of husband and wife, by the intrusion of a person other than the couple … infringe the child’s right to be born of a father and mother known to him and bound to each other by marriage. They betray the spouses’ right to become a father and a mother only through each other.” (CCC 2376).
In addition to the human cost, each IVF cycle can cost $15,000 to $30,000. Three to four cycles are often needed, so it could cost more than $100,000 for a woman to achieve a viable pregnancy, Hangge said.
The financial impact of the IVF mandate on Minnesota health plan members could grow to $28 million annually, according to an estimate released by the Minnesota Chamber of Commerce. The chamber also quoted the Minnesota Council of Health Plans (an association of nonprofit health plans), which estimates a cost of $12 per member per month, or as much as $154.4 million, in the fully insured market.
Fully insured firms pay a fixed premium per enrollee to a health insurance issuer, with the health insurance issuer bearing the risk for paying claims, according to a U.S. Department of Health and Human Services document.
Despite the cost, IVF’s overall effectiveness rate is just 37 percent, Oakes said.
“The desire for children is so strong that (couples) will try anything,” she said, noting that many of the couples she directs on archdiocesan engaged couple retreats approach her with fertility concerns. “And if they’re told this is your only hope, this is your only answer, women will just go through round after round after round after round.”
While IVF results in the destruction or abandonment of many human lives, it also increases the risk of cancer for both the mother and baby, Oakes said. In addition, many IVF providers seek to treat endometriosis only enough for women to be free of its effects for six to 12 months, depending on the window to try to conceive, Oakes said.
In endometriosis, tissue similar to the endometrial lining of the uterus grows outside the uterus, which can cause adhesions, scarring, internal bleeding, bowel or urinary dysfunction, constipation, painful intercourse, or infertility, according to the Endometriosis Foundation of America.
Nationwide, 12 percent of IVF-achieved pregnancies result in miscarriage if a woman is “struggling with a disease process in any way, shape, or form; the body will cut out fertility first,” Oakes said. “That’s what the body does to protect (itself). When you don’t treat the (underlying fertility) issue and when you try to force pregnancy to occur, the outcome is so poor.”
It doesn’t make sense from a health perspective to go around the fertility process, she said. “Rather, (one should) restore the health of the couple so that they can go on to live healthy lives and not have an increased cancer risk,” Oakes said. “Because even just the process of IVF alone, so many medications are utilized to stimulate the eggs and to go around hormones. It’s such a difficult process on a woman’s body.”
Couples can often conceive naturally by removing all endometrial tissue and treating other diseases that can cause infertility, as well as participating in approaches to fertility such as NaPro Technology (Natural Procreative Technology) or the Creighton Model FertilityCare System, which includes tracking a woman’s hormones, Oakes said.
Having health insurance cover IVF treatments isn’t a guarantee that couples will have successful pregnancies, because it won’t help them with what they most need, Oakes said. Infertility is a sign that the body needs help, she said. “When you treat them, when they receive true care, then the babies come.”
