
I never expected that call. When it came in December 2023, I was asked to join the Diocese of Jackson Historical Commission for the cause of Servant of God Sister Thea Bowman, a Franciscan Sister of Perpetual Adoration (FSPA) of La Crosse, Wisconsin. Sister Thea’s cause as a potential saint had received unanimous approval of the U.S. bishops in 2018.
The diocesan phase is foundational. Archivists gather sources and make them available to historians who read them and write their report on the candidate. The Roman Postulator of the cause requires a biographical note and an account of heroic virtue. I chose to write about Sister Thea’s virtue.
What prepared me? I am professor emerita of history at the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul. My teaching and research focus on the social history of American Catholicism. I have published extensively on Servant of God Dorothy Day, likewise on the path to canonization. A graduate course in the history of American Catholic spirituality proved valuable. Preparation for teaching provided me with broad knowledge of the history of the U.S. Church as well as of the Black American experience. The Diocese of Jackson learned about me through the first historian appointed to the Commission, my distinguished colleague, Professor Cecilia Moore of the University of Dayton in Ohio.
Bertha Elizabeth Bowman (1937-1990), who became Sister Thea, was a Black American who at age 9 became a Catholic convert and at age 15 a FSPA aspirant. The Jackson diocese has an informative website about Sister Thea at jacksondiocese.org/thea-bowman, which includes an excellent one-hour documentary about her life.
Every couple of months, the Historical Commission for Sister Thea’s cause met on Zoom to discuss our progress and seek guidance for any challenges. This brought together Sister Thea’s Roman postulator, Emanuele Spedicato, who explained Vatican requirements, and team members from Mississippi, Ohio, Wisconsin and me. FSPA archivists Meg Paulino and Sidney Paulson provided essential help with documents. The Jackson diocese, represented by its chancellor, Mary Woodward, provided guidance and unflappable calm in addition to initial access to digital documents written by Sister Thea and official papers. Over Labor Day weekend in 2024, Moore and I visited the FSPA archives in La Crosse and received a more complete set of documents on a flash drive.
Jesuit Father Christopher Collins graciously arranged office support at the University of St. Thomas, where I printed, then read thousands of pages of documents. Some were neatly typed or written in schoolgirl or convent cursive. Most were scrawled, barely legible notes, written on the run in preparation for a talk or retreat. My task involved finding and explaining evidence of heroic virtue. That meant that first, I needed to consult my Catechism of the Catholic Church for a review of the theological and cardinal virtues, plus the related virtues of chastity, obedience, poverty and humility.
After reading and annotating my copies, I typed relevant quotations under each virtue heading for easy access. The writing of the report is an academic exercise. Proper titles and archival locations are needed for each quotation and footnote. In January 2025, the archivist discovered that the titles of documents and citations from the SharePoint files were outdated and incorrect. The archival assistant helped match each document I had used with its proper citation. Painstaking corrections took an entire month.
As a historian, context is essential for understanding the past. Bishops in the Dicastery of the Causes of the Saints will read the positio, or position paper, prepared by the postulator, who reads all the documents and our reports. Sister Thea’s virtue will be more intelligible with historical context on race relations during her lifetime and spiritual influences, such as her immersion in Black American Christianity and later in Catholic spirituality. One obvious influence was that of St. Francis of Assisi, patron of the FSPAs. After explaining specific evidence of each virtue, I focused on what I found most significant about Sister Thea’s spirituality. My report ended with a short, annotated bibliography of reliable works on African American history and religious history.
When our work was nearly completed, I signed oaths that I would faithfully complete the work and respond truthfully to questions asked of me by the episcopal delegate. Questions pertained to whether I had met procedural requirements. Additionally, I commented about significant aspects of Sister Thea’s spirituality. My paper was 37 single-spaced pages with 172 footnotes. Others printed and organized documents and reports in Jackson. We each sealed one box with wax and ribbon.
The commission’s work completed, we celebrated in Jackson with a Mass of Thanksgiving, a sealing ceremony for two remaining boxes, and delightful social gatherings.
Klejment is a member of Lumen Christi who also regularly worships at Our Lady of Victory Chapel at St. Catherine University, both in St. Paul.
LAITY’S ROLE IN THE CANONIZATION PROCESS
Laity can play an important role in the canonization process, that is, if they choose to do so. Those who are officially on the path to sainthood proceed from servant of God to venerable, then with a verified miracle to blessed, and, with a second verified miracle to saint. Prayers of petition contribute greatly to the success of a cause.
The cause of a favorite holy person, such as Sister Thea Bowman, is helped by those who pray for her to intercede and grant a favor, a grace or a miracle. A guild is organized to help promote the cause by providing biographical information, perhaps testimonials and even a video. They often have a prayer request website link that permits a person to send an intention that others will pray for. When even a small favor or grace is granted, the petitioner should inform the guild. These show popular devotion to the holy person and indicate the person’s activity in response to prayer. Prayer cards are often available from the guild supporting the holy person.
It is essential for anyone wishing to support a specific cause that they ask for the intercession exclusively of one holy person. In at least one recent case, someone claimed that Dorothy Day had performed a miracle when their tumor disappeared without a trace. Upon interrogation by an official of the cause, it was discovered that the petitioner had prayed for Day’s intercession and Sister Thea’s. As a result, because it could not be determined who performed the miracle, it did not count for either cause.
— Anne Klejment
