
Sometimes it’s easy to think there are two kinds of Christians: Those who emphasize worship and piety and those who focus on living out their faith in the world. But in this column, continuing our study of Jesus, I want us to begin to see how, in the Gospels, such a division is not even thinkable. For the intentional communities that Jesus was founding were both a social revolution and a liturgical movement centered on the Eucharist. To see how this all fits together, we have to bring together the themes of kingdom and community (which we’ve been exploring) with the new themes of the Temple and the Last Supper.
The key passage that will take us into this is Jesus’ famous statement to Peter, “I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church” (Mt 16:18). Catholics are very familiar with this passage, pointing out as we rightly do that here Jesus is providing the divine basis of the Church as an institution and the papacy in particular. Yet in our focus on Jesus’ establishment of these formal aspects of the Church we have usually missed what would have been most obvious to Peter and the disciples, namely that Jesus is here saying that his own intentional communities were to be the new Temple. What do I have in mind?
Jesus said to Peter “on this rock I will build my church.” The word church is ecclesia in Greek and means assembly, gathering, congregation, and the like. But most important, it is the word that is frequently used in the Old Testament to refer to the community of Israel. When Israel gathered to worship, or when their alternative covenant-way-of-life is described, this word appears over and over again.
By my ecclesia — my assembly — then, Jesus is referring to the most visible feature of his ministry so far: the social movement that had grown up in response to his kingdom announcement. His small cells of disciples sharing life together — those loyal to his agenda — he was saying, were the true, renewed, Israel.
Church (ecclesia/assembly), therefore, does point forward to the establishment of the Church in later ages that was destined to fill the world. But it most immediately points to the local groups of followers who shaped their lives by Jesus’ teaching. And Jesus appoints Peter as the leader of these communities. On him Jesus would build the communities we call his Church.
But Peter was a nickname. His given name was Simon. Peter (Petros, in the Greek of the New Testament, or Kephas in Jesus’ Aramaic) means rock, so Jesus has dubbed this poor fisherman “Rocky.” Yet it is not often asked why Jesus might have chosen this particular nickname. At one level, a rock might simply be a good metaphor for someone who is to be the foundation of a community. But there’s so much more here than that.
In Jesus’ context, speaking of a rock upon which something is built would be an obvious reference to the Temple, and the famous rock on which its foundation was laid. Even today in Jerusalem, the Muslim site built where the Temple used to stand is called “the Dome on the Rock.”
When Jesus, speaking of Peter, says on this rock I will build my assembly, he is contrasting this rock (Peter) with the Temple rock in Jerusalem. He’s saying there’s a new Temple, on a new rock, and that this new Temple is the cells of disciples he was gathering, and that Peter was the head of them. The kingdom was here, as Jesus had announced, the new age was dawning, a new covenant was being made, and part of that newness was that this central symbol of the people of God had now found its fulfillment in the communities of his disciples. Jesus’ assembly — his renewed people of Israel —is the new center of God’s presence and work in the world — then and there, and here and now, too.
Next time we’ll take a look at just how controversial this claim really was.
Miller is the director of the Center for Catholic Social Thought at Assumption in St. Paul. He is the author of “We Are Only Saved Together: Living the Revolutionary Vision of Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker Movement.”
