A voice from heaven?

Father Connor McGinnis

Share:
Facebook
X
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Person praying alone in a church
iStock/gorodenkoff

Amid a windstorm, earthquake and fire, Elijah, in this weekend’s first reading, discerned God’s voice in the quiet whisper. Would that all of us could be like Elijah in discerning the voice of God! In discernment, we sort one thing from another; in this case, specifically, we sort God’s still, small voice from Satan’s and from our own internal voice (at least when it departs from God). In prayer and in our mind, whose voice are we hearing, and what is it calling us to do? Adding my own piece to the cottage industry of discernment advice, I propose four filters to help do this sorting.

The first filter: Among these voices or these options before me, do any depart from Scripture, Church teaching, or the natural law? God has already revealed himself and spoken through these things. The Bible, the Church, and even the very created order are his mouthpieces. So, if what we are “hearing” doesn’t fit with any one of these, then the voice is not from God.

The second filter: Among these voices or options before me, what is actually presently possible? This is especially helpful when we are trying to figure out a course of action. For example, if you apply to Harvard University, and get a rejection letter from Harvard, we can presume it is not God’s will for you to go to Harvard. God’s providence, his unfolding of the story of world history, is itself something that needs to be obeyed. So, if we are trying to kick down a door that is closed to us, it is probably not God’s voice we are listening to.

The third filter: What is encouraging me or what will enable me to best live out a life of virtue, especially of faith, hope and charity? This is meant to screen out selfishness, where we seek merely our own comfort, pleasure, or exaltation. However, it also calls us to cultivate those circumstances where it is easier, rather than harder, to live a life of virtue. To be selfless while also setting ourselves up to succeed in virtue is the key.

The fourth filter: What internal and external validations are present to help guide me? The chance encounter. The words of a faithful parishioner at church. Lasting convictions in prayer. Inner peace coming from and leading to love of and confidence in God above all else. Our own carefully reasoned judgment. Even our own desires. All of these can help give credence and weight to where God’s voice might be speaking or pointing. Seldom would any one of them be decisive (though sometimes they are). All of them can give us a meaningful hint as to where God is moving.

You might notice that the first two filters eliminate the more clearly bad options, whereas the last two filters help the good and the true rise to the surface more clearly. But let’s say you apply all of these. Then what? If we have multiple legitimate options before us, we simply choose. We take account of all of the above and then make a choice as the free and intelligent agents God made us to be. No outcome is guaranteed (that is where surrender comes in), and ultimately, there is only One who can make a choice and never be wrong. But at the end of the day, if we seek to be faithful to God and discern well as Elijah did, perhaps the above advice might serve to help readers to that end. I certainly hope it does.

Father McGinnis serves as chaplain at Providence Academy in Plymouth.


Sunday, Aug. 9
Nineteenth Sunday in Ordinary Time

  • 1 Kgs 19:9a, 11-13a
  • Rom 9:1-5
  • Mt 14:22-33

Share:
Facebook
X
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Related

Parishioners invited to contribute to Retirement Fund for Religious in December

Go out to John the Baptist for Advent

Waiting for Christ, with hope in our hearts

Free Newsletter
Only Jesus
Trending

Before You Go!

Sign up for our free newsletter!

Keep up to date with what’s going on in the Catholic world