
Last month we looked at Jesus’ nonviolent response, in the Sermon on the Mount, to the suspicion that he was gathering support for an armed revolt. We saw that his response was the difficult fourth option — the option the Church is still called to follow — beyond quietism, beyond keeping the status quo and beyond violence of all kinds.
Yet his opposition to violence means that, while Jesus was not for casting off the Romans by force of arms, he was no friend to their violence either. In fact, he has keen insight into the psychological effects of living under totalitarian regimes. In the story of the possessed man who lives among the tombs (Mk 5:1-20), the demons holding him captive are called Legion — a Roman military unit. This story happens in gentile territory, where the army is encamped, suggesting some sort of connection between the imperial order and demonic oppression.
In our own times we have become sensitive to this kind of connection, and the ways the spiritual-moral and physical-social orders are ultimately inseparable from one another. The citizens of Communist countries, for instance, have often suffered not only physically but mentally as well. It is here that our attention is drawn to this multi-sided reality of Legion in the Gospel.
Jesus goes on to cast Legion into some pigs — and they do themselves in by running into the sea. Jesus’ nonviolent stance is consistent, then: He calls his followers not to oppose Rome by the sword, but neither does he cozy up to the occupying power. The Legion story is an enacted parable of opposition to any culture, ancient or contemporary, built on the blade of a sword or the barrel of a gun.
But it’s not just Rome. Jesus also takes aim at his fellow Jews. He chastises the status quo keepers — the high priests and Sadducees — for maintaining the current order by bloodshed, including engaging in the same sort of tactics toward him that killed the prophets of the Old Testament. The result is that the current temple leadership is no different than any other murderers that have existed throughout history: upon you will come “all the righteous blood shed upon earth” (Mt 23:35).
Ironically, then, when those same authorities come out to arrest him in the Garden of Gethsemane on that first Holy Thursday, it’s that same violent order that they suspect Jesus of threatening. And this charge he definitively rejects: “Have you come out as against a robber, with swords and clubs to seize me?” (Mt 26:55). And when one of his followers turns out to have a sword, this is just another of many instances of the disciples’ failure to understand Jesus’ purposes. And it shows how much of a temptation such a solution continued to be. Disaster is perhaps only narrowly averted, as Jesus intervenes: “Put your sword back into its sheath” (Mt 26:52).
Yet the resort to force could hardly have been surprising. Jesus himself had foreseen that, despite all his teaching, such recourse on his behalf would inevitably be made, precisely by his followers, which would only serve to incriminate him. At that crucial moment, he had warned at the Last Supper, they would take up the sword, and this would only confirm the Jewish leadership’s suspicions. As he put it, it ensured that he “be counted among the wicked” (Lk 22:37). And yet his own teaching remained that “all who take the sword will perish by the sword” (Mt 26:52).
When, therefore, Jesus says, “Do not think that I have come to bring peace upon the earth. I have come to bring not peace but the sword” (Mt 10:34), this is not some unaccountable contradiction with the rest of his message. He means that with the rejection of his message of peace — by choosing the way of violence in any of the three parties’ forms — the world must inevitably descend into the “wars and reports of wars” (Mt 24:6) that characterize the only other path. Or, as he says as he rides toward the triumphal entry on Palm Sunday, weeping over Jerusalem, “If this day you only knew what makes for peace — but now it is hidden from your eyes” (Lk 19:42).
In Gethsemane, then, Jesus’ disciples give into the temptation to assimilate his revolution to one of the options already on offer, typical of other kings and kingdoms. And in Gethsemane, Jesus rejects that option for the last time.
Miller is the director of the Center for Catholic Social Thought at Assumption in St. Paul. He is the author of “We Are Only Saved Together: Living the Revolutionary Vision of Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker Movement.”
